Failure rates
3D printing failure rate: what is normal, and what it costs you
Beginners lose somewhere between 10% and 30% of prints; experienced operators lose 2% to 10%. Those are experience-based ranges, not measurements — and the page below turns whichever number you have into money.
What a failure rate does to your unit cost
A failed print still consumed filament, electricity and machine hours. To deliver one good unit at failure rate f you must start 1 ÷ (1 − f) prints. The table applies that to the 100 g PLA part from the cost breakdown, whose subtotal before failures is $1.79.
| Failure rate | Prints per good unit | Cost per good unit | Added by failures |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0% | ×1.000 | $1.79 | +$0.00 |
| 5% | ×1.053 | $1.89 | +$0.09 |
| 10% | ×1.111 | $1.99 | +$0.20 |
| 15% | ×1.176 | $2.11 | +$0.32 |
| 20% | ×1.250 | $2.24 | +$0.45 |
| 25% | ×1.333 | $2.39 | +$0.60 |
| 30% | ×1.429 | $2.56 | +$0.77 |
The curve is gentle at first and steep later: going from 0% to 10% adds $0.20 per unit, while going from 20% to 30% adds $0.32 for the same ten points. This is why a workshop that measures 25% should stop quoting and fix the process first — at that rate you are spending a quarter of your material and machine time on things nobody buys.
Put your own rate in
Enter the subtotal for one print attempt and your failure rate. The result is what each sellable unit actually costs.
Measure your own rate in twenty prints
Twenty is enough to know whether you are a 5% operator or a 25% one, which is the only distinction that changes a quote. Log every print for a month: model, material, spool age, outcome, and the reason if it failed. Count failures as prints that did not produce a sellable part — a print you stopped at hour two because the first layer was wrong is a failure, not a cancellation.
Then set the failure rate in the cost calculator to what you measured, not to what this page says. A measured 18% is worth more than an assumed 10%.
The four things that actually move the number
- First layer. Most failures are decided in the first two minutes. Clean the sheet, re-run the mesh levelling when you change a nozzle, and print a skirt wide enough to show you the flow is right before the part starts. A brim costs a gram and saves whole prints.
- Supports. Support that fuses to the part, or that the nozzle knocks over at hour six, is a process error rather than bad luck. Increase the Z distance, use a support interface, and orient the part so that large overhangs are supported by the bed instead.
- Wet filament. PETG, nylon, TPU and any spool that has sat open for months will pop, foam and delaminate. A dry box or a heated dryer is the cheapest reliability upgrade in the hobby, and it is the one most people skip.
- Broken meshes. A model with holes or inverted normals slices into something the printer cannot build. Check the file before you print it: the STL checker reports triangle count, dimensions, volume, watertightness and non-manifold edges in the browser, without uploading the model anywhere.
The honest summary: failure rate is a property of your process, not of 3D printing. The gap between 30% and 5% is mostly bed adhesion, moisture and mesh quality — three things you can fix this week, and three things that are worth 43% on the cost of every part you sell.
Where this number belongs in a quote
In the denominator, never in a vague "add 10% for waste". Divide by 1 − f, show it as its own line, and let the customer see it. The pricing guide does exactly that, and the arithmetic is the same one the calculator uses.